• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Site Directory
  • Home
  • Alex’s Lounge
  • P.O.U. Health and Fitness
  • POU Comments of the Week
  • P.O.U. Daily Link Sweep
Pragmatic Obots Unite

Pragmatic Obots Unite

Shooting down firebaggers & teabaggers one truth at a time...

Wednesday Open Thread: Black Songwriting Duos

October 28, 2015 by Miranda 294 Comments

There’s modesty and there’s modesty . Barrett Strong fell into the latter category as he looked back on the many songs he and former partner Norman Whitfield wrote as Motown staff writers during the Detroit soul label’s ’60s heyday. “We wrote maybe 300 songs and we had 12 good ones,” Strong, 49, said, speaking from his home in a Detroit suburb. “So 288 were bad ones.”

Pop music historians–and the charts–would beg to differ, not just with his dismissal of the vast majority of his catalogue, but with his terming the dozen best as merely “good.” “I Heard It Through the Grapevine” . . . “Papa Was a Rolling Stone” . . . “Just My Imagination.” . . . All rank among pop music’s classics, as close to timeless as the form gets.

The team’s songs, originally recorded by Motown acts including Marvin Gaye, the Temptations and the Jackson 5, have been recorded by acts ranging from the Rolling Stones to the California Raisins. As a body of work, the Whitfield-Strong oeuvre nearly rivals that of Motown’s other great team, Holland-Dozier-Holland.

Whitfield and Strong first teamed in 1960, when Motown was getting off the ground. Both were just out of high school. Strong was 17 when he was introduced to Motown founder Berry Gordy by singer Jackie Wilson, whom Gordy managed.

At 18 he had a hit, singing his own song “Money,” which was later recorded by the Beatles. But he was more interested in writing than performing, and Gordy put him and producer-writer Whitfield together. Along with Holland-Dozier-Holland and Smokey Robinson, Whitfield and Strong virtually invented a sound that is still one of the most influential in pop music.

“I guess you could say we invented it,” he said, giving credit for his songs’ distinctive arrangements and productions to Whitfield. “But we were quite young then and just doing something we hoped would work out, and it did. It was all teamwork, a family.”

Together, they wrote some of the most successful and critically acclaimed soul songs ever to be released by Motown, including “I Heard It Through the Grapevine” by both Marvin Gaye and Gladys Knight & the Pips; “War” by Edwin Starr; “Smiling Faces Sometimes” by the Undisputed Truth; and the long line of “psychedelic soul” records by the Temptations, including “Cloud Nine”, “I Can’t Get Next to You”, “Psychedelic Shack”, “Ball of Confusion (That’s What the World Is Today)”, and “Papa Was a Rollin’ Stone”, amongst others.

Strong received a Grammy Award for Best R&B Song in 1973 for “Papa Was a Rollin’ Stone.” Strong and Whitfield also co-wrote the ballad “Just My Imagination (Running Away With Me)”, a 1971 Billboard No. 1 that also marked the last Temptations single to feature original members Eddie Kendricks and Paul Williams.

“I don’t know if you could say I was trying to make it as a singer,” he said. “I’m a creative person and tried to see what would happen. It didn’t happen.”

Since then he’s focused his time on his family, though he still treats Detroit’s young musicians as his extended family, working with local artists.

“I don’t think most of them see me as a father figure–I’m not an old-looking guy,” he said. “But some of the guys I’m working with are into the older singers and they look at me as someone who can teach them something. And I look at them as having something new they can teach me.”

In a break from his modest demeanor, Strong said that little in today’s music compares to his Motown work: “There is nothing good out there anymore. There are great songs, but for solid R&B songs with the pop blend, there aren’t enough good ones. Everything is more technology oriented. You don’t have to be a good musician these days. People still enjoy that Motown sound: good solid songs, good singing and real musicians.”

(Los Angeles Times)

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: Barrett Strong, Norman Whitfield

Primary Sidebar

Recent Comments

  • People
  • Recent
  • Popular

Top Commenters

  • GreenLadyHere13
     · 222023 posts
  • Alma98
     · 205731 posts
  • rikyrah
     · 181686 posts
  • nellcote
     · 100353 posts

Recent Comments

  • LAMH

    I remember her from Teen Summit.

    Mahn...fuq cancer!

    RIP!

    Wednesday Open Thread: Stories from the Freedmen’s Bureau Records · 23 minutes ago

  • edp4bho

    Beautiful.....inside and out. Godspeed her journey.

    Wednesday Open Thread: Stories from the Freedmen’s Bureau Records · 31 minutes ago

  • conlakappa

    A righteous rant about medical governing board in England. Colonizers can just continue to perpetrate colonizing behavior, while suffering little consequence.

    Wednesday Open Thread: Stories from the Freedmen’s Bureau Records · 32 minutes ago

  • Alma98

    I'm glad all went well for your mama LAMH, i wish her a full recovery too.

    Wednesday Open Thread: Stories from the Freedmen’s Bureau Records · 33 minutes ago

Most Discussed

  • Wednesday Open Thread: Stories from the Freedmen’s Bureau Records

    comment · 14 minutes ago

  • Tuesday Open Thread: Stories from the Freedmen’s Bureau Records

    comment · 21 hours ago

  • Monday Evening Thread: The 2025 BET Awards

    comment · 1 day ago

  • Monday Open Thread: Stories from the Freedmen’s Bureau Records

    comment · 1 day ago

Powered by Disqus

Twitter

Tweets by @PragObots

Recent Posts

  • Wednesday Open Thread: Stories from the Freedmen’s Bureau Records
  • Tuesday Open Thread: Stories from the Freedmen’s Bureau Records
  • Monday Evening Thread: The 2025 BET Awards
  • Monday Open Thread: Stories from the Freedmen’s Bureau Records
  • Sunday Open Thread: POU Movie Day – Mama Flora’s Family

Tags

#HTGAWM #TGIT African American History African History Black History Civil Rights Movement Divas Forward Friday Open Thread Funk Grammy Winners Great Bands Hip-Hop How To Get Away With Murder Jazz Kerry Washington Legends Monday Open Thread Motown Records NFL Obama Biden 2012 Olivia Pope Open Thread P.O.U. Sunday Jazz Brunch POU Weekly NFL Picks President Barack H. Obama President Barack Obama President Obama R&B racism Rap Saturday Open Thread Scandal Shondaland Shonda Rhimes slavery Songwriters Soul Sports Sunday Open Thread Thursday Open Thread Tuesday Open Thread Video Viola Davis Wednesday Open Thread

Footer

A-F

  • African American Pundit
  • Afrospear
  • All About Race
  • Angry Black Lady Chronicles
  • AverageBro.com
  • Black Politics on the Web
  • Blacks 4 Barack
  • Blue Wave News
  • Brown Man Thinking Hard
  • Crooks and Liars
  • Democracy Now!
  • Democrats for Progress
  • Eclectablog
  • Extreme Liberal's Blog
  • FactCheck.org
  • Field Negro
  • FiveThirtyEight

G-S

  • GrannyStandingforTruth
  • Hello, Negro
  • Jack & Jill Politics
  • Latino Politico
  • Margaret and Helen
  • Melissa Harris Perry
  • Michelle Obama Watch
  • Mirror On America
  • Momma, here come that woman again!
  • New Black Woman
  • Obama Foodorama
  • Obama for America 2012
  • Positively Barack
  • Raving Black Lunatic
  • Sheryl Kaye's Blog
  • Sojourner's Place
  • Stuff White People Do

T-Z

  • Talking Points Memo
  • The Black Snob Feed
  • The Field
  • The Hill
  • The Mudflats
  • The Obama Diary
  • The only adult in the room
  • The Peoples View
  • The Reid Report
  • The Rude Pundit
  • The Starting Five
  • ThinkProgress
  • This Week in Blackness
  • Tim Wise
  • Uppity Negro Network
  • What About Our Daughters
  • White House Blog
  • Womanist Musings

Copyright © 2025 · Log in