• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Site Directory
  • Home
  • Alex’s Lounge
  • P.O.U. Health and Fitness
  • POU Comments of the Week
  • P.O.U. Daily Link Sweep
Pragmatic Obots Unite

Pragmatic Obots Unite

Shooting down firebaggers & teabaggers one truth at a time...

Tuesday Open Thread : Doo-Wop Music

November 1, 2011 by pragobots 120 Comments

GOOD MORNING P.O.U.!

We continue our look at Doo-Wop Music.

THE PENGUINS

The Penguins were an American doo-wop group of the 1950s and early 1960s, best remembered for their only Top 40 hit, “Earth Angel (Will You Be Mine)”, which was one of the first rhythm and blues hits to cross over to the pop charts. The song peaked at #8 on the Billboard Hot 100 chart, but had a three-week run at #1 on the R&B chart.

The original members of The Penguins were:

* Curtis Williams (December 11, 1934 – August 10, 1979) (bass-baritone)
* Cleveland Duncan (July 23, 1935) (tenor)
* Dexter Tisby (March 10, 1935) (tenor)
* Bruce Tate (January 27, 1937 – June 20, 1973) (baritone)

Duncan and Williams were former classmates at Fremont High School in Los Angeles, California, and Williams had become a member of The Hollywood Flames. In late 1953, they decided to form a new vocal group, and added Tisby and Tate. Their midtempo performance style was a cross between rhythm and blues and rock and roll. Williams brought with him a song, “Earth Angel,” on which he had worked with Gaynel Hodge, another member of the Hollywood Flames.[1]

The Penguins were one of a number of doo-wop groups of the period named after birds (such as The Orioles, The Flamingos, and The Crows). One of the members smoked Kool cigarettes, which, at the time, had “Willie the Penguin” as its cartoon advertising character. They considered themselves “cool,” and accordingly decided to call themselves “The Penguins.”[1]

Dootone Records released The Penguins’ single “Hey Senorita” in late 1954 as the intended A-side, but a radio DJ flipped the record over to the B-side: “Earth Angel” worked its way up to #1 on the Billboard charts (the only Penguins song ever to fly that high), and held that place for three weeks early in 1955.

Duncan sang lead on “Earth Angel.” He reprised his performance a decade later on Frank Zappa’s “Memories of El Monte,” an elegiac 1963 song in which he suddenly breaks into “Earth Angel” as one of the various songs remembered.[2] El Monte, a city near Los Angeles, had spawned such popular performers as Tony Allan, Marvin & Johnny, The Shields, as well as the Penguins. Those groups were also emulated as part of Zappa’s tribute to early days of rock and roll.

In a common practice of the time, radio stations frequently featured segregated playlists. Thus, “Earth Angel” was simultaneously recorded by the white group, The Crew-Cuts in 1955. The Crew-Cuts cover peaked at #3 on the Hot 100 chart, five spots higher than the Penguins version. The single’s success launched the Crew-Cuts’ own successful career of recording “crossover”-friendly covers of R&B hits. [Actually, the Crew-Cuts’ first successful cover was “Shboom” which hit #1 on Billboard in 1954]

The songwriting genesis for “Earth Angel” was a matter of some dispute, eventually ending up in a split credit between Penguins baritone Curtis Williams, Gaynel Hodge, and Jesse Belvin. The song had evolved through several Los Angeles area groups, and was based on the “Blue Moon” chord changes that were so popular with many doo-wop groups.[citation needed] The song was influenced by Jesse and Marvin’s #2 R&B hit “Dream Girl,” which contained many of the same vocal inflections used to great effect in “Earth Angel.” The “Will you be mine?” hook in “Earth Angel,” which was also the song’s subtitle, was borrowed from the #9 R&B hit of the same name by the Swallows.[citation needed] The Hollywood Flames had also recorded “I Know” in 1953, a song which has been called “a chord-for-chord blueprint for “Earth Angel,” and which featured the same Curtis Williams piano intro that Williams himself reused on the Penguins hit. The coda of “Earth Angel,” with the repeatedly harmonized word “You-oo… you-oo… you-oo… you-oo,” had previously been heard in the Dominoes’ #5 R&B cover of “These Foolish Things Remind Me Of You.”

(SOURCE: Wikipedia)

[youtube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MCkC2kg2KlQ?rel=0&w=420&h=315]

[youtube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t3ykKpDMsvU?rel=0&w=420&h=315]

The Penguins “Earth Angel” was the first “pure” doo-wop record. “Earth Angel” blended pop’s melodicism and lyrical innocence with the emotional directness of gospel and R&B. A classic “ballad with a beat,” the song is sung over a swaying piano triplets with sparse instrumental backing. The yearning lead vocal and ragged background voices created an amateurish” sound in the best sense.

The simple lyrics (“Earth Angel, will you be mine…”) have an innocence that the untrained voices and the “garage” sound only served to heighten. “Earth Angel” was literally recorded in the garage of Dootsie Williams, owner of Dootsie Records. The Penguins sound like what they were: a group of high school students singing a song for one of their girlfriends. The message of “Earth Angel” was “That it could be me,” by aspiring young singers who couldn’t imagine singing like The Ink Spots or leading a jump band like Louis Jordan, but could imagine writing or singing a song like “Earth Angel.” 1

(SOURCE: The History of Rock & Roll)

Filed Under: Open Thread Tagged With: Doo-Wop Music, The Penguins, Tuesday Open Thread

Primary Sidebar

Recent Comments

Powered by Disqus

Twitter

Tweets by @PragObots

Recent Posts

  • Monday Open Thread: The Life of Robert Reed Church (Chapter 1)
  • Sunday Open Thread: POU Movie Day – A Southern Haunting
  • Saturday Open Thread: African-American Military History: World War II
  • Friday Open Thread: African-American Military History: World War II
  • Thursday Open Thread: African American Military History – World War II

Tags

#HTGAWM #TGIT African American History African History Black History Civil Rights Movement Divas Forward Friday Open Thread Funk Grammy Winners Great Bands Hip-Hop How To Get Away With Murder Jazz Kerry Washington Legends Monday Open Thread Motown Records NFL Obama Biden 2012 Olivia Pope Open Thread P.O.U. Sunday Jazz Brunch POU Weekly NFL Picks President Barack H. Obama President Barack Obama President Obama R&B racism Rap Saturday Open Thread Scandal Shondaland Shonda Rhimes slavery Songwriters Soul Sports Sunday Open Thread Thursday Open Thread Tuesday Open Thread Video Viola Davis Wednesday Open Thread

Footer

A-F

  • African American Pundit
  • Afrospear
  • All About Race
  • Angry Black Lady Chronicles
  • AverageBro.com
  • Black Politics on the Web
  • Blacks 4 Barack
  • Blue Wave News
  • Brown Man Thinking Hard
  • Crooks and Liars
  • Democracy Now!
  • Democrats for Progress
  • Eclectablog
  • Extreme Liberal's Blog
  • FactCheck.org
  • Field Negro
  • FiveThirtyEight

G-S

  • GrannyStandingforTruth
  • Hello, Negro
  • Jack & Jill Politics
  • Latino Politico
  • Margaret and Helen
  • Melissa Harris Perry
  • Michelle Obama Watch
  • Mirror On America
  • Momma, here come that woman again!
  • New Black Woman
  • Obama Foodorama
  • Obama for America 2012
  • Positively Barack
  • Raving Black Lunatic
  • Sheryl Kaye's Blog
  • Sojourner's Place
  • Stuff White People Do

T-Z

  • Talking Points Memo
  • The Black Snob Feed
  • The Field
  • The Hill
  • The Mudflats
  • The Obama Diary
  • The only adult in the room
  • The Peoples View
  • The Reid Report
  • The Rude Pundit
  • The Starting Five
  • ThinkProgress
  • This Week in Blackness
  • Tim Wise
  • Uppity Negro Network
  • What About Our Daughters
  • White House Blog
  • Womanist Musings

Copyright © 2025 · Log in